Dirt. David R. Montgomery
Читать онлайн книгу.
and amateur archaeologist John Lloyd Stephens found the ruins of more than forty ancient cities in dense Central American jungle. After excavating at Copán in Guatemala, traveling north to Mexico's ruined city of Pelenque, and returning to the Yucatán, Stephens realized that the jungle hid a lost civilization. His revelation shocked the American public. Native American civilizations rivaling those of the Middle East didn't fit into the American vision of civilizing a primeval continent.
A century and a half after Stephens's discovery, I stood atop the Great Pyramid at Tikal and relived his realization that the surrounding hills were ancient buildings. The topography itself outlined a lost city, reclaimed by huge trees, roots locked around piles of hieroglyphic-covered rubble. Temple-top islands rising above the forest canopy were the only sign of an ancient tropical empire.
With different characters and contexts, Tikal's story has been repeated many times around the world—in the Middle East, Europe, and Asia. The capital of many a dead civilization lives off tourism. Did soil degradation destroy these early civilizations? Not directly. But time and again it left societies increasingly vulnerable to hostile neighbors, internal sociopolitical disruption, and harsh winters or droughts.
Although societies dating back to ancient Mesopotamia damaged their environments, dreams of returning to a lost ethic of land stewardship still underpin modern environmental rhetoric. Indeed, the idea that ancient peoples lived in harmony with the environment remains deeply rooted in the mythology of Western civilizations, enshrined in the biblical imagery of the garden of Eden and notions of a golden age of ancient Greece. Yet few societies managed to conserve their soil—whether deliberately or through traditions that defined how people treated their land while farms filled in the landscape and villages coalesced into towns and cities. With allowances for different geographical and historical circumstances, the story of many civilizations follows a pattern of slow, steady population growth followed by comparatively abrupt societal decline.
Ancient Greece provides a classic example of too much faith in stories of lost utopias. Hesiod, a contemporary of Homer, wrote the earliest surviving description of Greek agriculture about eight centuries before the time of Christ. Even the largest Greek estates produced little more than needed to feed the master, his slaves, and their respective families. Like Ulysses' father, Laertes, the early leaders of ancient Greece worked in their own fields.
Later, in the fourth century BC, Xenophon wrote a more extensive description of Greek agriculture. By then wealthy landowners employed superintendents to oversee laborers. Still, Xenophon advised proprietors to observe what their land could bear. “Before we commence the cultivation of the soil, we should notice what crops flourish best upon it; and we may even learn from the weeds it produces what it will best support.”1 Xenophon advised farmers to enrich their soil both with manure and with burned crop stubble plowed back into the fields.
Ancient Greeks knew about the fertilizing properties of manure and compost, but it is not clear how widely such practices were followed. Even so, for centuries after the revival of classical ideals during the European Renaissance, historians glorified the ancient Greeks as careful stewards of their land. But the dirt of modern Greece tells a different story—a tale of destructive episodes of soil erosion.
With thin rocky soils covering much of its uplands, only about a fifth of Greece could ever support agriculture. The adverse effects of soil erosion on society were known in classical times; the Greeks replenished soil nutrients and terraced hillside fields to retard erosion. Nonetheless, the hills around Athens were stripped bare by 590 BC, motivating concern over how to feed the city. Soil loss was so severe that Solon, the famed reformer of the constitution, proposed a ban on plowing steep slopes. By the time of the Peloponnesian War (431—404 BC), Egypt and Sicily grew between a third and three-quarters of the food for Greek cities.
Plato (427-347 BC) attributed the rocky slopes of his native Attica to pre-Hellenistic soil erosion following deforestation. He also commented on soil's key role in shaping Athenian society, maintaining that the soils of earlier times were far more fertile. Plato held that the soil around Athens was but a shadow of its former self, citing evidence that bare slopes were once forested. “The rich, soft soil has all run away leaving the land nothing but skin and bone. But in those days the damage had not taken place, the hills had high crests, the rocky plain of Phelleus was covered with rich soil, and the mountains were covered by thick woods, of which there are some traces today.”2 Seeing how harvesting the natural fertility of the surrounding land allowed Athens to blossom into a regional power, Plato held that the root of his city's wealth lay in its soil.
Aristotle (384-322 BC) shared Plato's conviction that Bronze Age land use degraded soil productivity. His student Theophrastus (371—286 BC) recognized six distinct types of soil composed of different layers, including a humus-rich layer above subsoil that supplied nutrients to plants. Theophrastus made a point of distinguishing fertile topsoil from the underlying earth.
Both Plato and Aristotle recognized signs that Bronze Age land use had degraded their region's soil. Several thousand years and several civilizations later, archaeologists, geologists, and paleoecologists vindicated Aristotle's estimate of the timing: farmers arrived about 5000 BC and dozens of agricultural settlements were scattered throughout the region by 3000 BC; cultivation intensified about the time Aristotle posited the first serious effects of soil erosion there. Such knowledge, however, did not prevent classical Greece from repeating the pattern.
Over the past several decades, studies of soils throughout Greece—from the Argive Plain and the southern Argolid in the Peloponnese to Thessaly and eastern Macedonia—showed that even the dramatic climate change at the end of the last glaciation did not increase erosion. Instead, thick forest soils developed in the warming climate as oak forest replaced grassland across the Greek countryside. Over thousands of years the soil grew half a foot to several feet thick depending on local conditions. Soil erosion began to exceed soil production only after introduction of the plow.
The first Greek settlements were located in valleys with good soils near reliable water supplies. As the landscape filled with people, farmers began advancing onto steeper, less productive slopes. Extensive tilling and grazing stripped soil from hillsides and piled thick deposits of reworked dirt in valleys. Ancient agricultural artifacts can still be found on the rocky slopes of areas that lack enough soil to grow much vegetation.
Figure 6. Map of ancient Greece.
Sediments trapped in valley bottoms, and remnant pockets of soil on the slopes themselves, record cycles of erosion and soil formation throughout Greece. The deepest layers of valley-filling sediments date from glacial to interglacial climate changes during the past quarter million years. Higher layers in the stack of dirt tell of more recent episodes of hillslope erosion as well as intervening periods when soils developed. The first postglacial deposits of reworked hillslope soils in the valleys generally date from the Bronze Age arrival of agriculture. Erosional episodes similar in outline, but different in detail, occurred across ancient Greece where farming spread out of the valleys and onto hillslopes.
Figure 7. Parthenon. Albumen print by William James Stillman, 1869 (courtesy of Research Library, the Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles, California [92.R.84]).
Soils of the southern Argolid, for example, record four periods of postglacial erosion during times of intensive land use. The first, from roughly 4500 to 3500 BC, was a time when thick woodland soils were widely settled by early farmers. Introduction of the plow and the spread of farming into steeper terrain led to widespread erosion around 2300 to 1600 BC. Hillslope soils gradually rebuilt during the dark age before the rise of classical Greek civilization. The area was again densely settled in late Roman times and another period of depopulation followed in the seventh century AD. About fifteen inches of soil are estimated to have been lost from Argolid uplands since the start of Bronze Age agriculture. As many as three feet of soil may have been stripped from some lowland slopes.
Valley bottom sediments of the Argive Plain in the northeastern Peloponnese also testify to four