Ethics in Psychotherapy and Counseling. Kenneth S. Pope
Читать онлайн книгу.
stupidity than we spend questioning and challenging ourselves in positive, effective, and productive ways that awaken us to new perspectives and possibilities. Questioning ourselves is at least as important as questioning others.
6. Most of us find it easier to question ourselves on those intriguing topics we know we don’t understand, that we stumble onto with confusion, uncertainty, and doubt. The harder but more helpful work is to question ourselves about our casual certainties. What have we taken for granted and accepted without challenge? Nothing can be placed off limits for this questioning.
Certainties are hard to give up, especially when they feel like they are part of who we are. They become landmarks, helping us make sense of the world, guiding our steps. But perhaps an always-reliable theoretical orientation begins distorting our view of a new patient, leading us to interventions that make things worse. Or having always prided ourselves on the soundness of our psychological evaluations, we keep rereading our draft report in a case in which an unbiased description of our findings may bring about a tragic injustice, harming many innocent people, and begin to wonder if our feelings for the client led us to shade the truth. Or the heart of our internship has been the supervision, and we’ve made it a point to tell the supervisor everything important about every patient, except about getting so turned on with that one patient, the one who is not very vulnerable at all and does not really need therapy, the one we keep having fantasies of asking out after waiting a reasonable time after termination and then, if all goes well, proposing to.
Questioning our certainties means actively and repeatedly seeking out and listening respectfully to those who disagree with us and engaging them in openly exchanging views. It means actively searching out articles and books that challenge—and sometime attack—our assumptions, beliefs, and practices.
We must follow this questioning wherever it leads, even if we venture into territories that some might view as politically incorrect or—much harder for most of us—“psychologically incorrect” (Pope et al., 2006).
7. We often encounter ethical dilemmas without clear and easy answers.
As we try to help people who come to us because they are hurting and in need, we confront overwhelming needs unmatched by adequate resources, conflicting responsibilities that seem impossible to reconcile, systems that work against the best interests of our clients, frustrating limits to our understanding and interventions, and countless other challenges. We may be the only person a desperate client can turn to, and we may be jerked every which way by values, events, limited time, and limited options. Our best efforts to sort through such challenges may lead us to a thoughtful, informed conclusion about the most ethical path that is in stark contradiction to the thoughtful, informed conclusions of a best friend, a formal consultant, our attorney, or the professional groups we belong to.
In the midst of these limitations, conflicts, disagreements, and complexities, we must make the best choices we can. We must each struggle to answer the question: What do I do now? And each of us must take responsibility for the decisions we ultimately make. We cannot shift personal responsibility for what we decide and what we do to another person, group, law, code, or custom. There is no escape from these struggles. They are part of our work.
8. We and our clients do not live in a vacuum. We live and develop in sociocultural contexts.
We are called to act in accordance with an ethic of human rights and social justice. We open our eyes and hearts to how discrimination, hatred, injustice, beatings, xenophobia, slavery, jail, starvation, torture, or genocide—based on factors like race, religion, immigration, culture, gender, sexual orientation, disability, politics—affect us, our clients, their families and communities, our supervisees, and the world we live and work in. We search for the most ethical response to social injustice. We don’t shrug our shoulders and turn away. We face these issues with courage, honesty, caring, and a sense of personal responsibility to respond ethically.
Notes
1 1 Professional standards are considered to be mandatory while guidelines are aspirational in intent and highly recommended for best practice.
Chapter 2 ETHICS IN REAL LIFE
Even the simplest ethical concept, standard, or guideline can fool us. We hear it in class. We read it in the code. We understand it. We can explain it in a test, give a lecture on it, or explain it to a jury. We know the concept, standard, or guideline, but it fools us when it shows up unexpected in the messiness of real life. It comes dressed in different clothes—and sometimes camouflage—and we don’t recognize it.
Therapy offers countless challenges to recognizing how a specific ethical concept, standard, or guideline might be helpful or vital. One reason is that concepts, standards, and guidelines tend to be abstract, general, and sometimes ambiguous. Another reason is that psychotherapy can be such a complex set of interactions between unique people. Yet another is that psychotherapy can serve as the intense focus of need, hope, risk, and expectation. Lives can be at stake.
In the midst of this work, as it actually happens in real life, it can be hard to recognize those moments when we need to consider an abstract ethical concept, standard, or guideline.
This chapter provides examples of those moments as they happen in the messy textures of real life. None is based on a specific case (and none of the people are based on an actual clinician or patient), but each represents the kinds of challenges that therapists and counselors face in their day-to-day practice.
In each of the following fictional scenarios, the clinicians were trying to do their best. Readers may disagree over whether each clinician met the highest or even minimal ethical standards, and such disagreements can form the focus of classroom discussions, case conference presentations, or supervision consultation. In at least one or two instances, you may conclude that what the clinician did was perfectly reasonable and perhaps even showed courage and profound ethical awareness. In some cases, you may feel that significant relevant information is missing. But in each instance, the professional’s actions (or failures to act) become the basis of one or more formal complaints.
As you read each scenario, consider the situation from the point of view of each person mentioned as well as a member of an ethics committee, licensing board, or jury hearing the complaint.
RECORDS
After a full day of Zoom and Facebook sessions with her clients, Dr. Soo sits down at the computer to update her clinical files, making sure all the notes, billing information, digital copies of the day’s Zoom and Facetime sessions (recorded with the full informed consent of her clients), and other records are current. She turns on the computer and … nothing. Just a blank screen. That’s never happened before. Wait: A message scrolls into view:
Greetings, Dr. Soo! I was able to hack into your computer—obviously!—and copy all your files. Yes, even your video files, which I found quite interesting. I even accessed those files you stashed in the cloud as backups. Your passwords weren’t much of a challenge for my software and finding your key to unencrypt your encrypted files was something I did while multitasking. I left your files on your computer, but I used a much more sophisticated program to encrypt them so that you can’t access them.
I’ll bet you’re upset, even angry, but you needn’t be. All can be set right as rain in just a step or two. All you need do is deposit $25,000 U.S. in bitcoin into the account specified at the bottom of the page within 72 hours, I’ll send you the key that will unencrypt your files, and you’ll never hear from me again.
Easy, isn’t it? A simple quid pro quo.
Oh, one more thing, Dr. Soo. What if you don’t pay within 72 hours? What if you think you don’t even need to pay because you’ve got another copy of all your records hidden somewhere on a disk that is not connected to the internet and so inaccessible to me and my merry band of fun-loving rascals? Well, you should know that were I not to receive the bitcoin within 72 hours—and I have